Re: [NGC4LIB] Google Ngram Results

Posting to NGC4LIB

On 14/03/2013 18:20, john g marr wrote:


I want to try to limit myself to trying to get catalogers just to recognize that the tool they have spent their entire careers building is broken.

You statement is logically invalid and glib in that is all-encompassing, absolute and not grounded is facts. I’ll believe it when people who use the tool start complaining about it in droves and then I’ll start fixing it in relation to the specific problems addressed by the complaints.

And of course, all of your statements are none of those things! 🙂

I was assuming that you had listened to my podcasts where I have gone to great pains to demonstrate how the catalog–fact–does not work in the way it was designed to do. To prove this is elementary. I have demonstrated this over and over again but if people do not want to accept that those are problems, I cannot force (browbeat) them. It seems as if many catalogers prefer to keep going in the same well-trodden paths and pretend that retyping all of those abbreviations and by decreasing access to catalog records by introducing the rule of one and introducing the relator codes, as RDA does, is going to bring people back to the catalog for some unknown reasons. I agree it’s easier to believe than to question.

I’m not alone in my belief that the catalog is broken however. Many out there believe that the catalog is simply inadequate for modern society and want to do away with it.
Others just hate the catalog on general principles,

At least I think that the problem is that the catalog is broken and therefore it can be fixed instead of just trashed. In fact, if it is fixed–really fixed–to work as it should and even better, I think it could serve in some small way to helping the world out there.

By the way, if you wait for people to complain before you decide that people have problems with your product, you’ll be waiting a long, long time. It is wrong to believe that people complain when they are unhappy. When you create something that no one wants and they can find something they prefer someplace else, people don’t complain–they just go away. When I go to a lousy butcher or a lousy restaurant here in Rome (yes, they exist) I don’t complain. I just choose a better one. People are doing that with our catalogs. In droves.

We have been watching this with our catalogs for years.